Cinema
Film review
Drama
author
Luciana Trost
Date
Share
Jean Cocteau (1889–1963) was a poet, playwright, art critic, painter, and French film director, as well as a close friend of major artistic figures such as Picasso, Modigliani, and the singer Édith Piaf. Some of his most renowned films include The Blood of a Poet (his first surrealist film, directed in 1930), Beauty and the Beast (1945), and Orpheus (1950), along with plays such as The Terrible Parents (1938) and The Eagle with Two Heads (1943). Cocteau distinguished himself in nearly every artistic field he chose to explore, immersing himself in the avant-garde movements of the 1920s and standing out in theater, cinema, dramaturgy, and painting. In 1930, he wrote The Human Voice, a long monologue that premiered at the Comédie Française in Paris and became one of his most celebrated literary works. He dedicated it to Édith Piaf, his close friend, although she never dared to perform the role.
The Human Voice tells the story of a woman abandoned by her lover, desperate to win him back and to hear his voice on the telephone one last time, prolonging the conversation in any way she can. What interests us in particular is the submission the woman shows toward her lover in Cocteau’s drama (“Oh, my love, do not apologize, it is natural and I am the foolish one”) and how this element takes a radically different turn in Pedro Almodóvar’s film adaptation. We offer a spoiler alert for those who have not yet seen the short film.


In Cocteau’s work, we witness a woman shattered by heartbreak and willing to do anything, even attempting to take her own life, in the hope of recovering a love she already knows is lost. Her submissive posture is evident. Although the text does not include the responses of her interlocutor, this becomes clear through the way she replies. The result is a supplicating and painful monologue that attempts to bring back to the surface a love that has already sunk.
Almodóvar’s adaptation remains faithful to Cocteau’s text up to the ending and therefore preserves some of its immanence. However, this is where the transcendence of Almodóvar’s version becomes clear. The protagonist chooses to empower herself and burn almost everything tied to that relationship, including the home they shared and, metaphorically, the version of herself trapped in that destructive bond. She finally manages to end the call by saying, “I am going to hang up now. I have to learn to hang up on you, darling. Goodbye.” This ending, radically different from Cocteau’s, introduces a measure of hope for a new beginning for the protagonist and also for the dog, since she reconciles with him and signals that a new life awaits them both.
We understand that this shift in the conclusion of Almodóvar’s film may relate to the visibility of certain contemporary notions, particularly the circulation of feminist ideals that advocate for a freer and more empowered woman. It also aligns with the coherence and freedom that have always shaped Almodóvar’s work, which often exposes the forms of subjugation experienced by women, the socially marginalized, and other minority groups today.
Share
Film credits
Original title
The Human Voice
Year
2021
COUNTRY
Spain
Director
Pedro Almodóvar
Screenplay
Pedro Almodóvar. Theatre play: Jean Cocteau
Cast
Tilda Swinton, Agustín Almodóvar, Miguel Almodóvar, Pablo Almodóvar
Music
Alberto Iglesias
Cinematography
José Luis Alcaine
Production companies
Coproduction: España-Estados Unidos; El Deseo, Filmnation Entertainment. Producer: Esther García
Distributor
Wanda Films & Avalon (Spain) - Sony Pictures Classics (USA)
Genre
Drama | Medium-length film. Theatre






